Post
Experience Project iOS Android Apps | Download EP for your Mobile Device

I Don't Believe Soldiers Are Heroes

Being part of the military does not make you a hero, dying in the military does not make you a hero 163 People

    No

    l beg to differ. This is really disrespectful to everyone who followed his/her ideals to help his/her country or someone else's country, who gave blood and even his life for someone else. Soldiers are the only kind of person that's not selfish. No selfish person ever got killed...
    EiPerkele EiPerkele 18-21, M 1 Response Nov 3, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Really? Because without the military you

    wouldn't have had the freedom of speech to even write this.
    0nlybittersweet 0nlybittersweet 22-25, F 3 Responses Feb 22

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Heroes

    A hero is someone who does something Heroic. Generally,  humanity seems to like altruistic heroism. My take on Soldiering as a profession is as follows. Unless you're conscripted. That's another matter. Soldiers follow orders. They position themselves within violent...
    chairmanmeow chairmanmeow 22-25, F 34 Responses Dec 3, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    In today's society, people respect soldiers.

    They say they fight for our country and for our freedom. I do respect their bravery in doing this but I honestly have no idea why there are wars and why we need soldiers to fight. Like what do you gain in the end? Why are they respected when they kill humans, people who are just...
    KarinaLin KarinaLin 18-21, F 8 Responses Apr 30

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Killing Never Makes You A Hero.

    No matter what you do, killing never makes you a hero. You know what makes you a hero? Protecting people. Making sure people are okay. Saving peoples lives. War is never the answer. And I disagree that soldiers are never heroes. I'm sure there are plenty that are but there is...
    vanilahairspray vanilahairspray 18-21 5 Responses Sep 14, 2013

    Your Response

    Cancel

    I feel bad for saying this.

    I love that our soldiers are brave enough to die for us. I am immensely appreciative. however, I don't agree with killing. I don't understand war, and maybe that's because I'm young and don't understand concepts this complex yet. but I know I would never be able to kill someone...
    maggieee5086 maggieee5086 16-17, F 4 Responses Apr 13

    Your Response

    Cancel

    IDE like to see where all of you haters would be

    if there weren't any soldiers.
    Rugby4me Rugby4me 18-21, M 1 Response Sep 29

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Old Billy Bones

    Theres a line about soldiers in an Irish pub song called Billy Bones  "crying over the darling little boys and girls"  its used after the whole songs been spent describing a violent horrible man who joined the army for the hell of it and got himself killed. Its what i think...
    Randomguy22 Randomguy22 18-21, M 4 Responses Feb 17, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Heroes

    How can anyone say that no soldiers are heroes? If that isn't than what is? In the World Wars it wasn't about oil or money, it was about freedom. If the soldiers didn't stop the Nazis in WWll, there would be no freedom, and many, many more lives would have been needlessly taken...
    NovemberRain1275 NovemberRain1275 18-21 3 Responses Apr 12, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Where I Live

    Where I live the main source of justice are the Marines(Navy). The marines are always trying to kill someone just because of there flags, i have been arrested several dozen times just because i have a tattoo of a certain flag, my point of view on the law is based off of this...
    srknrm srknrm 16-17, F Jul 21, 2013

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Agreed

    These people are in other countries, killing, stealing and disrespecting. They're going in there because the government tells them to. They're not fighting for ANYTHING to do with peace, freedom or love, they're there to get what their country wants from the other. I have no...
    Trecoolness Trecoolness 18-21, M 1 Response Dec 23, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Be Sure Of This, The Abu Ghraib Soldiers Were Not Heros.

    In fact, every fool who says "I was just following orders" while he/she takes part in a crime, is no hero.
    bitlord bitlord 51-55 10 Responses Dec 16, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    How could someone say this.

    Would you rather have more tragedies like 9/11 and sandy hook elementary school shooting? Military men clearly don't like killing people. It's not work it's liberty and fighting for our rights. How dare someone say they aren't Heroes! If we didn't have them our world would be a...
    2p35jm 2p35jm 13-15, F 6 Responses Dec 28, 2013

    Your Response

    Cancel

    I Am An American Soldier

    All I can say is that with the words, "I am an American Soldier" comes a great sense of pride, dignity, and honor. There are those that would argue that the youth are brain-washed or forced into serving, but I can assure those people that statement is far from the truth. Those...
    lightswillguideyou lightswillguideyou 18-21, F 8 Responses Apr 13, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Chomsky sums up my sentiment on the ultimate

    purpose of the "support our troops" propaganda. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7DdWmWUa_8
    ThatRedhairedGirl ThatRedhairedGirl 22-25, F 3 Responses Feb 23

    Your Response

    Cancel

    More Precisely...

    I don't believe that just being a soldier automatically qualifies you to be called a hero. I think you kinda have to actually do something to earn that. It would be like saying oranges are fruit therefore all fruit are oranges. Doesn't work that way.
    katnipkitkat katnipkitkat 41-45, F 1 Response Jul 21, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Not Heroes.

    I'm in Canada and every time a US solider dies it's splashed all over the news and everybody automatically labels that soldier a hero. It's like how many innocent Middle Eastern citizens did that one soldier kill (or accidentally catch in the cross-fire) before they died...
    nothingandsomething nothingandsomething 22-25, F 96 Responses Dec 15, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    There Is Something Wrong With You!!

    Really??? You don't think soldiers are heros? What ashame. Y don't you try defending your country then?? I can't believe someone would even make a group like this. They fight for your freedom!!! I believe you would be singing a different toon if there was no military. &...
    Graham31 Graham31 22-25, F 17 Responses Jul 13, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    My View.

    If you don’t want to stand behind them, feel free to stand in front of them. I’ve been horrified by the number of people who automatically judge me or my boyfriend when they find out he’s in the military. It’s a way of life that in Australia especially...
    ammylouise ammylouise 18-21 28 Responses Jul 13, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    American Soldiers

    A few words of support from Across the pond. American politicians frequently take bad decisions and make mistakes. They're are human but the world is a much safer place because of two countries Great Britain and the United States of America. Until each lazy cowardly person...
    wigeon wigeon 41-45, M 1 Response May 22, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    "We have an obligation to every last victim of

    this illegal aggression because all of this carnage has been done in our name. Since World War II, 90% of the casualties of war are unarmed civilians. 1/3 of them children. Our victims have done nothing to us. From Palestine to Afghanistan to Iraq to Somalia to wherever our next...
    Bewail Bewail 22-25, F 6 Responses Sep 28

    Your Response

    Cancel

    I Think This Is Obvious

    one. how many individual soldiers to you know who decided right i am going in the army to fight for my country ? two. how many do you know went in to boost their ego ? three. how is promoting war heroic ? if their was no soldiers no-one would feel at threat. having soldiers/army...
    Johnny88 Johnny88 22-25, M 26 Responses Jan 23, 2011

    Your Response

    Cancel

    I think it's just disgusting what the western

    world is doing to the rest of the world, and middle east especially. This absurd is getting so ridiculous, first the USA created Al Quaida and the Talibans in order to use them against the Soviet Union, later they armed Saddam so that he can fight the Iran, and then when they...
    Vrime Vrime 22-25, M 1 Response Oct 2

    Your Response

    Cancel

    This page is absolutely disgusting.

    Whoever created it clearly lacks intelligence.
    kelseyynicoleeb kelseyynicoleeb 18-21, F 1 Response Jan 9

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Just To Add To This

    thought i'd might as well make a story about it considering its just getting filled with crap. the point of this group was orginally that people who join the military aren't automaticly heros. you have to earn it first, soldiers have dont terrible things and good things. some do...
    lmpulsive lmpulsive 18-21, M 24 Responses Dec 19, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Pawns!

    Soldiers are brainwashed pawns fighting for a regime not of their own but led to believe and 'sold' to them as their own!!  More or less lied to really so I can't hate them..Man what a world - In all honesty this may sound f#%@ed up but I really can't wait til the world ends...
    juantwo juantwo 26-30, M 35 Responses Dec 16, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Imagine A World Without Soldiers:

    Where there is no one to protect the innocent. Where children play in cemeteries because it is the only safe place that isn't riddled with land mines placed by militant forces overthrowing the government. Where political factions blockade merchant vehicles on roads, kidnapping...
    XxNikkixKatoxX XxNikkixKatoxX 26-30, M Nov 20, 2013

    Your Response

    Cancel

    As Nam Era Vet And An Enlisted Soldier In The Gulf War, My Experience Spans Considerable Time!

    I found the enlisted ranks were much more likely to contain heroes than the officer ranks, even though I had family in both.  I had a number of friends among the protesters, not one was a hero, most were cowards.  I would put President Clinton in the coward category!  I did...
    SmrtGuyUT SmrtGuyUT 61-65, M 2 Responses Sep 5, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Awful. Of course soldiers are heroes.

    They risk their lives in terrifying situations constantly to keep civilians safe and to protect the rights of their country.
    alexxaaa alexxaaa 18-21, F 1 Response Jan 31

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Wow!

    This group is so wrong for so many reasons. i cant believe there are seven of you people. how do you call yourselfs americans? our boys are over there giving their lifes to keep you A**H**** free. someone has to fight for our freedom and i just thank god to every service man and...
    ashleyolsen1919 ashleyolsen1919 18-21, F 17 Responses Jul 17, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    One thing I am totally sick of hearing from

    Americans military personnel is, "Don't be so ungrateful! I'm fighting for your freedom!" No. No you're not. First of all, I live in New Zealand. We aren't at war with anybody and yet we have been voted the freest country on Earth, funny that. Secondly, you are NOT fighting a...
    Bewail Bewail 22-25, F 8 Responses Sep 4

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Well They Can Be... But They Aren't Always.

    There have been heroic soldiers in the world, no doubt about it.  From many countries, in many ages, people have given their lives and their effort and their labour and their dreams selflessly for others.  And some of these people have done this during war time. ...
    GoldenArrow GoldenArrow 31-35, M 2 Responses Dec 16, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    A Child's Guide To Us Foreign Policy

    A Child's Guide To United States Foreign Policy Q: Daddy, why did we have to attack Iraq? A: Because they had weapons of mass destruction honey. Q: But the inspectors didn't find any weapons of mass destruction. A: That's because the Iraqis were hiding them. Q: And...
    OEclecticO OEclecticO 31-35, F 10 Responses Dec 17, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    I Disagree

    We can go back and forth about this all day. No one likes war, I admit it there is nothing to like about it. But don't take it out on the heros. You can have your own opinion. Thats your thoughts and I can't change that. But that gives you no right to go calling out soldiers. I...
    FreedomFighter10 FreedomFighter10 13-15, F 2 Responses Apr 29, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    This is the most shameful

    and disrespectful thing I have ever read. They sign up and fight so you don't have to and no one else wants to. The military is hard mentally, emotionally, and physically. The Army values are Loyalty, Duty, Respect, Selfless service, Honor, Integrity, And Personal courage. The...
    ofmiceandmegs ofmiceandmegs 18-21, F 3 Responses May 22

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Here Is A Suggestion.

    Get off your ungrateful, pathetic *** and YOU go fight a damn war to defend your family. I am sickened at this.
    BellasHappyPlace BellasHappyPlace 18-21, F 14 Responses Dec 15, 2009

    Your Response

    Cancel

    In today's modern Society.

    .. No... A good example... Look at Iraq before and after the invasion.
    MrIndeedNL MrIndeedNL 13-15, M 7 Responses Apr 13

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Would you like a foreign country's military

    coming to the United States and killing your family? Because that's what our military does to other countries. Our troops go there and terrorize innocent people.
    Gophillies8 Gophillies8 22-25, M 1 Response Apr 13

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Shameful

    Anyone who says our soldiers are not heroes should be completely ashamed of themselves. It takes a selfless kind of soul to sign up to voluntarily go to war. My grandfather was a WWII veteran who fought at the Battle of the Bulge. My dad signed up as a teenager during Vietnam. My...
    pfcpremosgirl pfcpremosgirl 36-40, F 5 Responses Nov 9, 2012

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Whoever made this page is

    so stupid I must say that. Who are you to say that men and women who serve our military aren't heroes ? Have you ever walked in their shoes on a daily basis ? Do you know what life is like for them ? Most likely you don't. And don't give any stupid answer like "a family member...
    Neshaxo Neshaxo 16-17, F 7 Responses Jun 24

    Your Response

    Cancel

    It's great that soldiers cared enough to fight

    for our country. But a hero is definitely NOT someone who goes to other countries and kills other people. It's stupid to kill people, and for what? Money, oil, power? I don't believe in war.
    alysssaa alysssaa 13-15, F 3 Responses Jul 21

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Wow

    Wow! I cant get over there even being a group like this.Soldiers are not Heroes?I hope You think of that every time You use Your freedom of speech on EP or else where.
    The1960texan The1960texan 51-55, M 2 Responses May 30, 2013

    Your Response

    Cancel

    Related Experiences

    I used too, something happened, and now I don't believe anymore.
    ClassicGentleman ClassicGentleman 18-21, M 27 mins ago

    Your Response

    Cancel
    I don't believe in superstitious legends. I don't believe in any other superstition. I don't believe in all things that are part of peoples small-time gossip. More to the point, I...
    SamHarris SamHarris 22-25, M Oct 7

    Your Response

    Cancel
    I don't believe in happiness in love.I used to but now not so much. I believe that love brings us pain and honestly in my opinion all of the great loves are sad. And for something...
    ThatBlueOwl ThatBlueOwl 16-17, F 4 Responses 1 day ago

    Your Response

    Cancel
    I really don't believe in Love anymore. I don't think I ever will believe in Love again either. Love is just not for me anymore.
    SouthernBella89 SouthernBella89 22-25, F Oct 12

    Your Response

    Cancel
    People ask me "Do you believe in God?" I say "No God isn't real" They ask me "why?" The real reason I don't believe in him is because when I was younger my parents would fight. I...
    nataly160 nataly160 13-15, F 3 Responses Sep 27

    Your Response

    Cancel
    I'm almost to the point where I don't believe in TRUE love. It just really sucks... My friend, Ben told me all about her girlfriend. She told him that she'll love him forever but...
    Misaki7590 Misaki7590 16-17, F 2 Responses Oct 12

    Your Response

    Cancel
    Someday I'll leave this place, I'll leave behind the friends I've made but keep the memories of our happiness in my heart. But someday I'll return cuz I don't believe in goodbyes...
    LuckyGuy001 LuckyGuy001 13-15, M 1 Response 6 days ago

    Your Response

    Cancel
    Long distant relationships don't work there are other people that you might fall for you need someone to be there with you to hug you, love you, if your not there with them you'll...
    gwen160000 gwen160000 13-15, F 2 Responses 1 day ago

    Your Response

    Cancel
    But what if the world really did end in 2012... What if we are all dead and this is the afterlife? (I don't actually believe this it just sounded kind of interesting)
    indigostory indigostory 13-15, F Sep 22

    Your Response

    Cancel
    I don't shave my down area. Why because nobody special to me. My boyfriends at the time don't like it but whatever you don't like it You must not be my soulmate
    lorrena19 lorrena19 18-21, F 19 Responses Sep 21

    Your Response

    Cancel