Resolved Question

I'm listening to The Mollusk right now, my favourite disc by them.

Go fetch me a nun from a dungeon deep
and water from a stone
and white milk from a maiden's breast
that babe ere never known

Funny story. Ween is from my neck of the woods and one night I was at an open mike night to see a friend play. I was sitting in booth sideways, facing out, and this dude came and sat next to me in the bench connected to mine at the next table. He sat the same way, so our heads were very close together. I kept feeling him look at me, and when I'd turn to meet his gaze he would quickly look away.

A few months later, I was watching Conan O'Brien and Ween was the band. They closed in on the lead singer and I recognized him immediately as being this person who sat beside me at John and Peters for open mike night.