Thicker AND longer. Sometimes, depending on position and my partner's shape, the fit isn't good enough for me to stay in where I put it. Longer would increase likelihood of maintaining penetration, while also increasing nerve endings which means more pleasure with every thrust and withdrawal.
Yup..whenever they put that hot fudge sundae down I think, "but..it looked bigger in the picture :("
Always. I'm average so yes I do. I always wonder what it would be like for a woman to pull it out and then have that OMG moment before she puts it in her mouth or elsewhere.