Post
For instance, a person of European decent writes a book about Asian, or African Amercians. Would it turn you off from wanting to read the work, or does it even matter to you? Just trying to get some feedback. =)
paclark paclark 31-35 16 Answers Apr 21, 2012

Your Response

Cancel

As a white Anglo-Saxon protestant (WASP) male, I have a book kind of inching it's way towards the page - but already my WASP male lead character has met with a sticky end.<br />
<br />
:-(<br />
<br />
(Probably, he deserved it.)<br />
<br />
But the story wants to carry on with a totally different hero... So, yes, this is a question I've been asking myself.<br />
<br />
I want an Asian girl (if you see what I mean) but am I up to the challenge?<br />
<br />
In fact, more accurately a British Asian girl living in the US. So far, I haven't plucked up courage to take the next steps.

Best Answer

You should do it. I would buy that book. =)

Best Answer

An author should be able to write about whatever he or she wants. <br />
<br />
What I would care about was whether or not it was factually correct or whether it accurately reflected the group about which he or she was writing.

Best Answer

It depends on how much research the author has done on it and how much the author has actually had contact to the ethnic group. But just to write a book with a biased opinion to spread more bad rumours about certain ethnic groups I find is a not a good idea. This is one reason so many people get the wrong impression of certain cultures because they have read things written by "outsiders" who don't really know the true traditions and reasoning behind that culture. They see everything only at face value and don't look into the why's and wherefores of any particular tradition, culture or belief.

Best Answer

It wouldn't matter at all as long as the author knew what he or she was talking about

Best Answer

No, it doesn't matter if the writer knows what they're doing, can tell a story well and has insights into the culture that would resonate with those within.

Best Answer

No

Best Answer

hell NO ... as long as he doesnยดt publish it ... lol

Best Answer

No, seeing how outsiders think can help deal with stereotypes and misconceptions.

Best Answer

If he used a lot of resources or at least lived there for a considerable time then he may be able to do it. He may not know a lot of things though and may miss some important details.

Best Answer

depends on how they go about it some try to hard to be what they are not and it shows in thier work

Best Answer

Related Questions