Taking a guess that in her family, talking about problems may have ended up making things worse.<br />
She either fears your reactions (because of the reactions of others in the past), or feels shame about her thoughts or feelings (not necessarily rational shame, could be something quite minor.)<br />
Best way to overcome fear is to face it.<br />
You sound to me as though you can already handle discussions very well, so just be with her while she struggles with herself, and keep gently encouraging her and being willing to sort it out. Eventually she will realise that it really is OK, and even preferable, to talk about it.

Best Answer

Her father and her could never talk anything through with her mom. Mom was always too stubborn. Eventually they both gave up reasoning with her and let her make all the decisions. Thank you for your answer. You make it easier for me to stay by her and wait through this.

Best Answer

btw, are you some sort of counselor by profession? : P you were very analytical and thoughtful given the little information I gave. Although what you've advised me to do in the end is what I've been trying to do for awhile, there is a level of understanding and care that is very reassuring and helps push me on. I will stay by her side most definitely and you are helping hold me up. Thank you.

Best Answer

She might be taking after her mom, too; if you quit, she wins.

Best Answer

I did counsel as a trained volunteer (Rogerian method) for Lifeline in Australia for 2 years or so... have also done lots of work on myself. You're welcome to contact me any time if you feel like it. Thanks for your very nice words. :)

Best Answer
1 More Response

I don't like talking about things I can't fix it is a total waste.I myself hate stress I try to dodge it and it is wonderful,I know where she is coming from.

Best Answer

even if most of the things are actually quite easy to fix? If you do understand where she's coming from, I'd be really interested in how you think I should approach this. She really wants to open up. I see it every time she snaps out of a break down and she's so happy then, so happy to be back beside me. If you could give me anything to help understand what she's going through, I would be very very grateful.

Best Answer

ir, from all that you'e said here it sounds to me that you've ceded all of the power in this relationship to her, and I don't imagine that "solving" that problem really interests her. You can't "make" anyone happy except yourself; she determines what makes her happy. Myself, I'd bail, but if you enjoy riding the emotional roller coaster, go for it.

Best Answer

meh I'm used to the roller coaster, I got bipolar. Leaving's not an option unless she speaks to me plainly and tells me she would rather not be with me. I want to see this through with her and hopefully we'll come out the other side both happy. Thank you for your input though, every answer makes me think about things a different way and helps me with this issue.

Best Answer

I wish all of the best for you, ir.

Best Answer

give her a hug and tell her you're there no matter what :) and if she can't talk about it let her write it all out and you can read it later

Best Answer

for some reason that usually makes her more stressed out : / once she's been triggered, there's not much I can do to undo it. It seems like the emotional and irrational thinking must take it's course.

Best Answer

If you want to make the relationship work, let her either approach you with her problems on her timetable (as long as you are not harmed) and be the calm, steady, manly stabilizer, or (gasp) leader. If you don't think you can continue the relationship with her as she is now, tell her such.

Best Answer

I tried waiting for her and giving her time (a year even), but it feels like if I don't push sooner or later, it will eat away at her driving her slowly away from me and making her more depressed and stressed, which causes more of these episodes.

Best Answer

Get out while you can. A year? F*** that. Tell her to grow up and tell you what the problem is or else you are going to assume that it's fine. Remind her that you aren't a mind reader. <br />
<br />
Although... If you've been together for awhile - everyone's getting engaged around you - you haven't really talked about anything like that - and 'if you don't know, I won't tell you' is the attitude... Well. She might be wanting some massive show of committment or something. I don't know. I'm not a mind reader either - but this has been the cause of a couple of my girlfriends melt-downs recently. <br />
<br />
Good luck man.

Best Answer

She has agreed to marry me, but many times through these episodes of hers she denies such saying things like "what if it was all a lie?", "I don't ever want to see you again", and "I have no promises with you". She deleted my number multiple times, thrown me out in the winter at past midnight multiple times, but sometimes she holds onto me pleading that I help her to stop doing this and pleading me to help her stop hurting me. We have agreed to go see a psychologist or counselor, but that was when she wasn't in one of these episodes. I thought we were finally out of it.. guess not.

Best Answer

oh man

Best Answer

ya it kinda sucks. I just want her to be happy

Best Answer

Related Questions