PrincessMaine PrincessMaine 46-50, F 11 Answers Dec 8, 2013 in WTK

Your Response


Why is Madiba's and America mourning a great accomplishment for America. A leader is as strong as a nation standing behind a leader. We mourn our Madiba as a nation we are proud that he lead us into reconciliation peacefully as a nation we put aside our differences and worked with each other as opose to against each other. We accepted the changes as one nation. Madiba would have wanted all South African's to remember we are one nation.

Best Answer

People have suddenly forgotten that he was classified as a terrorist until 2008 and was a known associate of dictators and terrorist leaders

Best Answer

You make me cringe.

Best Answer

I have read all these comments, and am completely confused. What is the question supposed to mean? What does Mandela's death have to do with the United States?

Mind you, at least one of the people responding seems equally odd.

Best Answer

What I am going to write here will doubtless make me unpopular with some readers, even if only because they will assume that what follows about Nelson Mandela is disrespectful. It is not.

So let me start by recognising Mandela’s huge achievement in helping to bring down South African apartheid, and make clear my enormous respect for the great personal sacrifices he made, including spending so many years caged up for his part in the struggle to liberate his people. These are things impossible to forget or ignore when assessing someone’s life.

Nonetheless it is important to pause during the general acclamation of his legacy, mostly by people who have never demonstrated a fraction of his integrity, to consider a lesson that most observers want to overlook.

Perhaps the best way to make my point is to highlight a mock memo written in 2001 by Arjan el-Fassed, from Nelson Mandela to the NYT’s columnist Thomas Friedman. It is a wonderful, humane denunciation of Friedman’s hypocrisy and a demand for justice for the Palestinians that Mandela should have written.

Soon afterwards, the memo spread online, ******** of el-Fassed’s closing byline. Many people, including a few senior journalists, assumed it was written by Mandela and published it as such. It seemed they wanted to believe that Mandela had written something as morally clear-sighted as this about another apartheid system, one at least the equal of that imposed for decades on black South Africans.

However, the reality is that it was not written by Mandela, and his staff even went so far as to threaten legal action against the author.

Mandela spent most his adult life treated as a “terrorist”. There was a price to be paid for his long walk to freedom, and the end of South Africa’s system of racial apartheid. Mandela was rehabilitated into an “elder statesman” in return for South Africa being rapidly transformed into an outpost of neoliberalism, prioritising the kind of economic apartheid most of us in the west are getting a strong dose of now.

In my view, Mandela suffered a double tragedy in his post-prison years.

First, he was reinvented as a bloodless icon, one that other leaders could appropriate to legitimise their own claims, as the figureheads of the “democratic west”, to integrity and moral superiority. After finally being allowed to join the western “club”, he could be regularly paraded as proof of the club’s democratic credentials and its ethical sensibility.

Second, and even more tragically, this very status as icon became a trap in which he was forced to act the “responsible” elder statesman, careful in what he said and which causes he was seen to espouse. He was forced to become a kind of Princess Diana, someone we could be allowed to love because he rarely said anything too threatening to the interests of the corporate elite who run the planet.

Best Answer

It is an indication of what Mandela was up against that the man who fought so hard and long against a brutal apartheid regime was so completely defeated when he took power in South Africa. That was because he was no longer struggling against a rogue regime but against the existing order, a global corporate system of power that he had no hope of challenging alone.

It is for that reason, rather than simply to be contrarian, that I raise these failings. Or rather, they were not Mandela’s failings, but ours. Because, as I suspect Mandela realised only too well, one cannot lead a revolution when there are no followers.

For too long we have slumbered through the theft and pillage of our planet and the erosion of our democratic rights, preferring to wake only for the release of the next iPad or smart phone.

The very outpouring of grief from our leaders for Mandela’s loss helps to feed our slumber. Our willingness to suspend our anger this week, to listen respectfully to those leaders who forced Mandela to reform from a fighter into a notable, keeps us in our slumber. Next week there will be another reason not to struggle for our rights and our grandchildren’s rights to a decent life and a sustainable planet. There will always be a reason to worship at the feet of those who have no real power but are there to distract us from what truly matters.

No one, not even a Mandela, can change things by him or herself. There are no Messiahs on their way, but there are many false gods designed to keep us pacified, divided and weak.

Best Answer

American? What? What do we have to do with this? I'm sad too, everyone who knew what he did is sad.

Best Answer

I'm sad, though I didn't personally help him get there, I'm sure he would hate all the talk he's getting right now since he wanted peace not peace through morning

Best Answer

I don't actually care. People die everyday, I didn't know the guy personally, and what he did/didn't do has no bearing on me. Might be cold, but I, unlike those who cry over every death like they really cared, am being honest.

Best Answer

Oh brother.

Best Answer

you think we wanted Mandela dead?? screw you

Best Answer

Well, we did classify him as a terrorist until 2008

Best Answer

what the hell man? he deals with his sh!t in SA he can't possibly affect USA, the greatest country on the face of the Earth

Best Answer

Then why did the US classify him as a terrorist for decades?

Best Answer

to stop him from coming to USA or marrying an American

Best Answer
1 More Response

Related Questions