It's a total compliment.I never say that but I have been around guys that have said that and women that have said someone was out of their league as well.
you guys are idiots ******* omg well first of all it mean thats girl is too good for the guy and he feels as if he isnt good enough for her. It is in a way a compliment unless the girl loves him then its not really a compliment OKAYY GOSHHH GET THAT **** RIGHT
It means, that he thinks less about himself.
Go and listen to Jordan Sparks: Next to you.
Then you will understand.
No it usually means he's not good enough for her from his point of view.
I think it means she's too pretty for that person or so he thinks. One never knows unless one asks.
It's usually a compliment or a sign that he has low self esteem. Typically, if you're going to use that phrase to imply that a person isn't good enough, you say that -they- are out of their league.
ie., "You're a great guy, but when it comes to that girl, you're out of your league, son."
its a statement of fact