Home  >  Culture and Religion  >  Religion and Spirituality  >  Resolved Question
Resolved Question

If Buddhism claims there is No Self, how can a person remember their past lives?

How, if there is no abiding self, can one have a series of past lives? It seems to me that this would require an individual soul, which contradicts many teachings of Buddhism.
Posted 4 months ago
Share |
   Flag
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker
Good point. I'm not 100% sure of this, but I think the denial and ultimate nonexistence of the self is the end goal, thus we keep getting reborn until we figure out how to let go of ourselves and become a part of the whole.
Posted 4 months ago

Other 6 Answers to If Buddhism claims there is No Self, how can a person remember their past lives?


Posted Jul 8th, 2009 at 12:21PM
it could have something to do with the idea of an absolute and relative reality. The absolute reality of Buddhism is emptiness, and "no self" would fall into that. Ultimately, there is no self. But when you are living in the world, in one of these lives, your perception is that there is. I'm guessing that, that which perceives this separation, or your consciousness, extends back in time, so that a series of seemingly separate "selves" are connected together, giving you the series of lives that you will remember as "your" past lives. (in other words, your illusory self of separation in this current life is an extension of your illusory separate self in the last life, and lives before that. the unit of illusory separation did not stop at your deaths and births)

But now I wonder...If there ultimately is no self, despite the fact that people remember past lives as "their own," are all of those past lives your and everyone else's lives? In other words, do we all share all past lives, and are we all right now, each other's "past" (or current/simultaneous, or future) lives? (of course this is assuming that time is not linear...I think Buddhism says time is an illusion anyways...actually, everything is an illusion anways so I guess it really doesn't matter...)
Rated: +2Vote for this!  
Posted Jul 8th, 2009 at 12:21PM
This is one question you can not answer from reading about Buddhism or it's philosophies. If there is no self, best meditate on this. By the way, if you meditate on sounds or music you may hear the gaps between the notes.
Rated: +2Vote for this!  
Posted Jul 8th, 2009 at 1:53AM
im sure i knew the answer to that question at one time.
Rated: +1Vote for this!  
Posted Jul 7th, 2009 at 10:20PM
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebirth_(Buddhism)
Rated: +1Vote for this!  
Posted Jul 7th, 2009 at 10:29PM
There is no permanent self. The self that is in everyone is one self. Each life represents a mortal self. Yet, even though everyone dies, our intelligence implies a supernatural phenomenon.
Rated: +1Vote for this!  
Posted Jul 8th, 2009 at 12:18AM
Shifting between the physical and metaphysical here, I could contend that past life memories are simply implants acquired after birth. I could also contend the since all atoms are recycled, there is a possibility that you DO have an atom or two in your body which once belonged to Cleopatra. (Theres a "Zen" thought for you) So if memory is atomic, then you may have a few "moments" that are genuine. However as a part of the universe, we all exist, always have and always will. (Using the same atomic theory) The goal is to get off the ride at Nirvana.
Rated: +1Vote for this!  
   1-6 of 6 Answers   
Questions and Answers powered by Ask Experience Project. Get answers to questions from the world's largest collection of life experiences, and the people who have had them. A huge, friendly, and fast wiki of answered questions! This page is for providing answers to the question, If Buddhism Claims There Is No Self, How Can A Person Remember Their Past Lives?
Answers to questions like If Buddhism claims there is No Self, how can a person remember their past lives? are provided for entertainment purposes only. You should never use answers to questions provided here to replace professional advice, such as from a doctor or lawyer.
Anonymous & Free
to join millions in the world's largest community of life experiences
Explore first-person stories about any experience, including your own! Connect anonymously with people who understand.
↓ ADVERTISEMENT ↓

Got Questions? We've Got Answers!
Ask Your Questions to members
who have been there and done that!
Share Your Knowledge
Learn Something New

Go Ask Experience Now!

Be YOURSELF

Be a part of the biggest social experience on the web. Where who you are is more important than who you know. Share what matters the most and find others who just "get it."

Join now and get started in seconds, or learn more about Experience Project

↓ ADVERTISEMENT ↓
EP Videos

Watch videos submitted by members that relate to their experiences.
See Experience Videos

Of course, we love to hear Your Story, whatever it happens to be. You can be yourself here!

Questions For You
↓ ADVERTISEMENT ↓