Post
Lyddia Lyddia 31-35, F 10 Answers Jul 25, 2011

Your Response

Cancel

Like anything it depends on the circumstances...<br />
At best he was a jerk at worst I would say yes it could be considered criminal in some circumstances.

Best Answer

we all have choices, they ultimately did it and it is incredibley selfish to do it because someone told you to do , and it is incredabley selfish to blame yourself for it or think you made them commit a crime??? why to the second, because you are just seeking self pity for a cruel reqest that you had no way of making take that pill, jump off that bridge etc we all have a choice. no matter what , nothing is good or bad it just is.

Best Answer

If there's not there should be. Anyone who tells someone to kill themselves has problems, and the justice system should figure out the mental intent of that individual and deal with them accordingly. To me, it's murder, your weapon of choice: someone elses' hand. <br />
<br />
Imagine this: If you were with someone and as you both stood in a room together, you encouraged them to pull the trigger. Kept telling them, "do it, do it". And they did- THAT'S MURDER. Our perception is altered a bit by thinking of the individuals being apart at the time the incident occured, BUT I I guarantee, that "do it, do it" would be playing in their mind like a broken record. Same situation... It's murder.

Best Answer

No, You didn't take their life...they did....but in the case of bullying..a person can be pushed to their suicide by a combination of factors, one of which being what kind of people are around them..(even families can unwittingly cause suicide by over criticizing or expectations beyond the scope of a rejected child) ultimately it is the victims own responsibility to 'stand up' to toxic people as part of growing better as a person..but unfortunately some would rather die than do that

Best Answer

No,unless they assisted the person in some material way - otherwise it would just be either hearsay,or a ba<x>seless allegation.

Best Answer

Technically no, but they are probably a horrible person.

Best Answer

yes, you could go to jail with charges of manslaughter. and if you tell them to but they don't and they report you, you can get fined $25,000 and 10+ years in prison for encouraging suicide

Best Answer

Related Questions