Both but personality and intellect come first
There's this thing. I am afraid of liking guys just for their personality. No, it is not because of their ugliness. Because most of them do have beautiful hearts. But I can not tell you how many times my heart has broken over liking guys only for their personality. Because, when you like someone's personality everything about them becomes beautiful. And well, sometimes their personality changes over time, and they're not the same sweet and nice guy that you've fallen head over heels for. They've become a jerk. But, because you liked them for their personality, you still hope that it's still in there somewhere. And when you can't bring then back? Well, then you have just became heart broken. So I like to stay safe and have crushes on guys for their looks. and fall in love for guys who have both (personality and looks)
w/o a good personality ,,, looks hardly matter
Right now I am feminizing myself so I am concerned with how I look. In others, personality is most important. I really don't care how they look.
Personality and intelligence will encourage my interest first. I find that liking someone as a person will actually make that individual become more physically attractive to me. I start noticing things that didn't strike me before. Similarly, if I meet a good looking guy who steadily starts showing a jerky side, he will become increasingly less attractive physically.
Personality no matter what
looks fade, personalities become enhanced
i'm kinda shallow and superficial.. i demand both ;)