Register

Religious People: How can you all be right? (read details)

There are so many religions in existence today, and there have been many more deities and divine beings in the past. So how can you be sure that the God you were brought up to believe in is really there? What makes, say, a Catholic right, and not a Jew or Muslim or Hindu person right?
And if it is the same God, or same idea, only interpreted differently, then why fight over it?
The religion you are is based on where you were born. If someone who is a devout Catholic was born in India, he would have been a devout Hindu, or Sikh instead.

Is This A Good Question? (8)

Add an Answer to "Religious People: How can you all be right? (read details)"

Send me an email when there are new answers to this question

14 Answers to "Religious People: How can you all be right? (read details)"

  1. knightwhispers - 56-60 years old - male

    Posted by knightwhispers Jan 1st, 2012 at 11:58AM

    It can be said that *everyone’s* interpretation of who God is … is correct. Religion can be said to be forced onto everyone of us depending on where we are geographically born; a Muslim is unlikely to be a Christian and vice-versa. Atheist have long since argued that there is no God … not even the *one* God if there was such God in whom all worshipped the same. But in any event, a Muslim may not worship any God as those living in the Christian nation may not worship any God either. That leaves *choice* to believe and that gets missed when the topic arises. We each have a *choice* and atheist / none-believes alike tend to lean on people being forced to believe.

    Different religions hold different interpretations, but the essence of them all is Faith and Hope in believing. It’s possible that the varying religions could have been born of the *one* belief, and therefore ‘transferred’ in regard to context. For those who believe their God is *the* God holds credence to my way of thinking; they can’t all be right, and if a person is religious, then one must be right and so, geographically, his God is the only God. But no matter how I think about this, on a personal level, a person who believes in God walks in Faith. And for those who don’t believe in God, I often ponder on how there is such a fuss about a person who’s *only* ‘guilt’ (as far as they are concerned) is that of having Faith which they don’t have.

    One God, many God’s, right God’s or wrong God’s. Is it really so bad that a person walks in Faith and Hope? Regarding wars? Wars are fought in the name of religion only, not in the Spirit of any religion. Saddam Hussein gave a perfect example of what could be done in the NAME of religion. In the later days, when he was losing hit battle he declared it to be a ‘Holy War’. He did this as an attempt to move his nation into taking up arms and fighting. What he did not do was call his nation to arms in the name of any God.

    [Edit] I am not a practicing Christian nor do I belong to any other religious sect. But I have studied the Bible.

    ~F~

    Like (2)

  2. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 5:41PM

    It is all very well if a man can walk in the path of faith and hope without having destructive influences on those around. If it is happy and beneficial for him then so be it. But it's when religious people start to preach one absolute truth, and start to hate against others in the name of his "faith" that he has gone too far, and he has left any common sense behind him.

    Like (1)

  3. knightwhispers - 56-60 years old - male

    Reply by knightwhispers Jan 2nd, 2012 at 11:40AM

    It's a huge debate and one where any of us can pick and choose 'elements' to prove our pleasure or our displeasure; the same can be said of none-believers. There are those who would say they continue to learn within their Faith ... there are those without Faith who declare they need know no more. It goes full circle; the person who has the Faith, the person who has Faith in nothing. It will *always* be Faith which is the driving force of the believer and it will be disbelief which turns the none-believer away. No matter how many generations the fight for and against religion carries on, the base line from where beliver and none-believers is that of Faith. Holding that Faith or choosing to not have that Faith. Millions of words have been written by scholars in both camps ... they both stand on the line where they started. It starts and ends in either Faith or no Faith; from there we can argue for and against into eternity. That is how it is at it's base and that is how it is at the simplest form. The rest are merely words of enforcement. ~F~

    Like (1)

    2 more replies
  4. LonexWolf - 18-21 years old - female

    Posted by LonexWolf Jan 1st, 2012 at 11:05AM

    It's not something I think about that way. I have studied other sects of Christianity and found that they don't resonate with my heart. I have studied Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism, Confucianism, and read sacred texts and verses. None of it resonates with my heart in the same way the Bible does. None of it gives me a shiver when sung in song form, none of it soothes my soul deeper.

    So I'm nondenominational, and I just pray for guidance on where to go and what to do from there, as I don't care for the division within one religion as it is, but still respect it. And although I have a profound respect for other religions, I just know they are not for me.

    Sometimes people believe what they want to believe and what they are capable of believing, based on what they were raised as. Education of other religions can help break those barriers, and either bring you closer in your current faith or stronger in a new found faith.

    Like (2)

  5. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 11:33AM

    Very good, enlightening answer. I respect that you made your choice based on experience of other religions, and stick with what you feel more comfortable with. In a similar way I choose not to believe because I don't feel the drive within me to agree with varying dogma. I understand that you feel right in believing in your faith of choice, and I respect that choice and respect people who can act well and sensibly in religions. It is only those who cannot respect the diversity and use religion as the reason to do wicked things that should not be respected.

    Like (1)

  6. LonexWolf - 18-21 years old - female

    Reply by LonexWolf Jan 1st, 2012 at 12:21PM

    I agree with your last statement there. Thank you for being so respectful in your response!

    Like (1)

    1 more reply
  7. olddreams - 56-60 years old - male

    Posted by olddreams Jan 1st, 2012 at 11:00AM

    I am certainly with you on the idea that you can't know. It is impossible to prove or disprove the existence of God, Heaven, Hell, spirit, and ghosts. However, religion serves many worthwhile emotional and social functions. Despite the general impression that religious people are violent, hateful, radicals, most religious people are compassionate and loving, even if somewhat tribal and clickish.

    Believing your God is the "one true God" gives weak egos the feeling of importance. It allows them to feel loved and protected which can be beneficial to mental health. As a social organization, they reach out and provide services to the poor, sick, and disadvantaged, that we as a society (America) are increasingly unwilling to do. There competition to show that their God is the more compassionate is beneficial to those in need of help.

    Most Christians dislike the hate mongering Christians as much as any responsible and compassionate individual. Most Muslims hate the radical clerics that spout hate and call for violence, just like any responsible and compassionate individual does.

    I think I drifted off topic. I guess my point is, they can't know, but they can believe. If that belief is beneficial to them and society, what is wrong with it?

    You believe they are wrong. They believe you are wrong. If we can't prove that God does or doesn't exist, how can you know who is right?

    Like (2)

  8. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 11:12AM

    Very valid and well thought out answer. I do not wish to criticize religion on the whole as being and evil, or plague upon humanity as some more extreme atheists or agnostics do. Religion does have many wicked aspects, such as genital mutilation in some religions, and patriarchy driving the society. However likewise it has given rise to many great men and been in inspiration to many arts and other positive aspects of culture. And I take your point, in that atheism also belongs in the "we can't all be right" argument. And I do believe in the absence of superior power, and that is just as valid as you believing in its presence. Thank you for the answer.

    Like (1)

  9. BluOmni - 31-35 years old - female

    Reply by BluOmni Jan 1st, 2012 at 9:31PM

    Old dreams... Also take into account how a person views "God" when considering whether its existence can be known or not. For instance my idea of "God" is that "God" is that quantum level and macro level infinite system of energy of which everything is intertwined with... every atom, every molecule of the known Universe and all of the unknown Universe and Universes. "God" as Omnipresent can only lead one to the conclusion that "God" is everything, everywhere as an energetic system interconnected in the illusion of time and space and beyond time and space................................................................ Who has the Absolute truth.. that does not change even with experience or discovery?

    Like (1)

    1 more reply
  10. tomario - 46-50 years old - male

    Posted by tomario Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:36AM

    perhaps they are all wrong :)

    Like (2)

  11. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:44AM

    That's what I believe, but I'm interested in hearing from the believers points of views.

    Like (1)

  12. tomario - 46-50 years old - male

    Reply by tomario Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:58AM

    as it all comes down to faith...anybody or anything could be a god! i have faith in my friends...does that make them gods???

    Like (1)

    2 more replies
  13. preciousHrt - 36-40 years old - female

    Posted by preciousHrt Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:34AM

    Well I believe in the Father/Son and Holy Spirit...I do not like labels I simply believe in just was I stated. My husband explained it to me like this...that what I see as God that other religions for them it is the same but just in their culture how they were raised that is what each knows. I am not so sure on that one because each religion has their own ideas. I do however love all people and respect their views. And I suppose we will all find out one day. I am not sure if this helps but just my thoughts on it. :)

    Like (2)

  14. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:39AM

    So you are saying that each religion's "god" is one and the same original being or force? But well done for being accepting of other views. I respect any person's views who can respect others' views.

    Like (1)

  15. preciousHrt - 36-40 years old - female

    Reply by preciousHrt Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:43AM

    Ty and yes that is how my hubby explained it to me anyhow..:)

    Like (1)

    2 more replies
  16. EarthlingWise - 41-45 years old

    Posted by EarthlingWise Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:34AM

    Good luck with that.

    Like (2)

  17. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:55AM

    Thank you haha

    Like (1)

  18. blingblogbloop - 26-30 years old - female

    Posted by blingblogbloop Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:32AM

    They all secretly believe they are THE ONE.

    Like (2)

  19. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:55AM

    Well that clearly can't be true of everyone though.

    Like (1)

  20. AnonymousCatholic - 22-25 years old - male

    Reply by AnonymousCatholic Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:57AM

    Or not so secretly! There are 3 religions (namely Islam, the R.C.C., and L.D.S.) I think of at the top of my head that are adamant about the one true faith.

    Like (1)

    2 more replies
  21. MontiPora - 56-60 years old - male

    Posted by MontiPora Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:31AM

    Welcome to the sentient population. You have seen the evidence and made up your own mind. That marks your first step into enlightenment. It will get easier now.

    Like (2)

  22. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:32AM

    I've long been an enlightened member of the sentient population, if I may say so. I just want to hear a religious person's views on this argument against them. It's good to hear every angle.

    Like (1)

  23. sunrise2013 - 41-45 years old - female

    Posted by sunrise2013 Dec 17th, 2012 at 2:17AM

    re-ligo / re=again; ligo=league, connection
    Thats going to show we are separated of God? Who has done that?
    Religions are just a way to rule the crowds, dressed up in traditions of the region they have been created.
    btw. I'm believer
    and not native speaker

    Like (1)

  24. watchman4u - 70+ years old - male

    Posted by watchman4u Mar 20th, 2012 at 4:25PM

    Sorry, you are wrong in your assumptions. There are two religions. The true one and the false one.
    The true one is the Christian belief as described in the holy scriptures. The false one is the Babylonian Mystery Religion as mentioned in the book of Revelations, chapter 17, verse 5. The Babylonian Mystery Religion is Satan's counterfiet of the true religion. It comprises a mother and son plus a third father figure. All religions were developed from the counterfeit religion devised by Satan.

    Like (1)

  25. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Mar 24th, 2012 at 3:48AM

    What makes you so sure the Christian belief is the true one?

    Like (1)

  26. BluOmni - 31-35 years old - female

    Posted by BluOmni Jan 1st, 2012 at 9:48PM

    Religion, philosophy, spirituality, personal wisdom from life experience..... Which one is more influential in one's life? ........ Personal wisdom from life experience. Why? Because it was created by the individual. A person's personal wisdom from life experience may be influenced by outside "forces" but experience will override. A person's personal wisdom or relative truth is right. This truth is malleable as time goes on and experiences help us learn new lessons. Relative truth is connected to a person's life experience so it is their reality which is similar but always unique to the person.

    People can debate and argue points of one's ideas but at the end of the day no one knows enough to flat out declare someone is "WRONG.". We only know what is relative. Even at present, science is relative to the times. Absolute truth or reality is the opposite of relative truth. Relative truth is relative to time and space, therefore, Absolute truth is NOT associated with time and space. Absolute truth withstands the test of time and doesn't change... Meaning: All discoveries would have to be made and cannot be affected by someone's perception. Since every human colors the world with their personal perception and there is so much left to be know even in science, one can conclude people in space and time cannot know the Absolute Truth.

    There is only ONE even if our CNS's tell us differently... Science says we are all ONE.

    Like (1)

  27. ladyrhiannon824 - 22-25 years old - female

    Posted by ladyrhiannon824 Jan 1st, 2012 at 2:38PM

    they are arrogant and irrational and all think that they are THE ONE right way of being...they believe all others will be cast into hell for all eternity.

    Like (1)

  28. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 5:33PM

    Not the most enlightened view, but thanks nonetheless.

    Like (1)

  29. Paschar - 61-65 years old - male

    Posted by Paschar Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:40AM

    Translation = read the last page of the Book , In Summary it means If you change anything in this book you'll get your's in the end ( And Not the way you wanted it ) .

    Like (1)

  30. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 5:48PM

    I'm afraid I don't follow.

    Like (1)

  31. Paschar - 61-65 years old - male

    Reply by Paschar Jan 1st, 2012 at 6:02PM

    Book of rev : / Last page of the Bible , Add nothing to the Book or take anything out / RE: Banned from the Bible scriptures and so forth .

    Like (1)

  32. AnonymousCatholic - 22-25 years old - male

    Posted by AnonymousCatholic Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:40AM

    The religion you are is based on where you were born? Are you forgetting about all of the converts (whether to Islam, Catholicism, etc.)? However, it is true that some faiths (Jews and Hindus come to mind) are strongly connected with ethnicity.

    Like (1)

  33. daur0s - 18-21 years old - male

    Reply by daur0s Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:43AM

    I am referring to the religion you start of with. Anyone can convert to and from anything nowadays, true enough. But people converting this way and that surely undermines the validity of any of their beliefs? If a Jew converts to Catholicism, and a Catholic to Judaism Someone's got to be wrong.

    Like (1)

  34. AnonymousCatholic - 22-25 years old - male

    Reply by AnonymousCatholic Jan 1st, 2012 at 10:52AM

    No, I do not see that way. Whatever people believe doesn't change the truth (if a group of people think that there are green elephants who live in the sea does not make it fact!). But yes, not all religions can be right (sorry, I am not a universalist). However, they all seem to have at least a grain of truth.

    Like (1)

    3 more replies

Ask A Question

Answers to questions are provided for entertainment purposes only. You should never use answers to questions provided here to replace professional advice, such as from a doctor or lawyer. This page is for providing answers to the question "Religious People: How can you all be right? (read details)"