The great psychologist Sigmund Freud once said 'America is a mistake, a giant mistake'. Was he right? Why or why not?
15 Answers to "The great psychologist Sigmund Freud once said 'America is a mistake, a giant mistake'. Was he right? Why or why not?"
-
Freud was also a cocaine addict. I think he and his whole field of pseudo science is a fraud.
Like (10)
-
Freud was a psychiatrist not a psychologist. Freud had a lot of issues.
Like (7)
-
I guess even psychiatrist has issues. They are human like all of us.Like (1)
-
-
Just saying the "Great Psychologist Sigmund Freud" is a mistake.
It is a matter of opinion as to whether he was great or not. Personally I think he was a quack that was hell bent on making EVERYTHING relate to sex no matter what it was.Like (6)
-
Agreed.Like (1)
-
-
He was stoned on coke at the time.
Like (6)
-
It's so easy to say that coke destroy her mind . I don't think , addicted people are less cliver . Indeed , it could be the drama .
Like (1)
-
i wouldnt worry much about this particular statement.coming from yet another man who spent his life tryng to get women, what does he know about mistakes:d
Like (5)
-
Freud was a quack.
Like (3)
-
Haha , it's so stupid , to be so categorical .
Like (1)
-
Sigmund Freud postulated that women have 'penis envy'... He was a nutcase.
Like (2)
-
Also that sons wanted to bang their mothers, daughters wanted to kill their mothers and marry their fathers, etc. oh, and his theory of anal stages and maturity of female ******* (vaginal vs clitoral). HOGWASH.
Like (1)
-
Bravo!
Like (1)
-
He must have been an Obama supporter. He and Obama are as wrong as you can be. America is the greatest place on earth because of the personal ability to be what ever you want to be.
Like (2)
-
Freud was a psychiatrist and the father of psychoanalysis.
Like (2)
-
He's right. You can buy the book when it comes out.
Like (2)
-
Mister FREUD was a genius , i am french ,as i am far from you , i can see all the mistakes ....it's so easy .
I am affraid because (we) follow you ..
I don't want to be like you .
I mean , i don't want to be the "well thinkings" american people .
So ...he was right , of course .Like (1)
-
Not only it is mistake, it is a crime. First, it stole the land from its rightful inhabitants and put them in reservations, like cattle. Then it built its riches by importing millions of slaves from Africa. And today it has abot 1,000 military ba
ses worldwide to stage coups against elected chiefs-of-state, murder women and children worldwide and protect the interests of the same multinationals who oppress and starve the world and their own people in America. Fortunately this is ending and we'll be free of that giant mistake. Like (1)
-
I wouldn't say America is a mistake...Lots of people belong to this country.
Dr. Sigmund Freud had his views.Like (1)
-
maybe. I recall his son or was it his grandson Clement being a liberal m.p. And advertising chum or winnalot dogfood with Henry, his blood hound in the 60's.
Like (1)
Best Answer (Chosen By Asker):
Posted by Woodwose Apr 27th, 2012 at 8:48PM
Maybe Freud described America as a mistake, not as an insult, but as a compliment? you see, you could say America was a huge Mistake, because it did not follow the worn path of other Countries, it made its own rules and laws, gave people the room to decide what they want to be, and provided the opportunity for them to do so. So the "Mistake" was that America was never meant to be this way, it was expected to follow the examples of other Countries, maybe even make the same mistakes as them. So Freuds apparent insult, might just in fact be a compliment? you were never meant as a Country, to go the way you have, but you did, and have achieved some wonderful things.
[ Reply ] | Like (1)