Post
I personally think that the Arabs have instigated the vast majority of it. The Jews are simply retaliating.
ellaballerina ellaballerina 18-21, F 9 Answers Nov 20, 2012 in Hobbies

Your Response

Cancel

The subtext of your question sounds like this is specific to the Palestinian Territories/Israel conflict. This is complicated. Horribly complicated and the history goes back to the end fo WWI (well before, really, but bear with me) and about western interventionism in the middle east.



But if we look at what's happening right now... well then who is responsible for what? Why they're fighting in the first place? Read a history book because it's a long story.

Most loss of life? Israel.

Most damage to infrastructure? Israel.

Most attempts to block a permanent, peaceful situation? Israel.



What people don't get is that Gaza is occupied territory. A hostile force controls the borders. The quality of life inside is atrocious. Extreme circumstances breeds extreme behaviour and so groups like Hamas rise up and do what they can to end the occupation. Lobbing rockets is stupid, it won't work, but they're desperate. Also, the rockets SUCK. Look up some videos of those things exploding.



Meanwhile, if one Israel dies, Israel sends in the troops and kills hundreds of civilians. Men, women, children - doesn't matter. Everyone dies. Israel have what is probably the best military in the world. They have the keys to peace. They are using their power to slaughter the people they're already oppressing.



To use a somewhat extremist metaphor, it's like pinning a puppy to the ground with your foot on its neck. And when it bites you, you kill its entire family. Hamas are no puppy, but that's the difference in power we're talking here.

Best Answer

I blame the islamic states in the region. They have historically been opposed to any progress and seem to favor the 7th century over the 21st. There were no democracies in the region before Israel was founded and as of today only Iraq has joined the list of democracies. I believe the muslim states are afraid that if their own populations see how much better Israeli democracy works, the tyrants will be overthrown so the tyrants use antisemitism to inflame their ignorant populations.

Best Answer

Israel, as a democracy, is progressive and advanced. But the Islamic states still continue to live in a very progressively impoverished state. The people are enormously oppressed and starved of unbiased and objective education on what is really happening in the Middle East. People all over the world keep pledging for peace, but the only way that will happen is if progression prevails of oppression and tyranny.

Best Answer

I blame Hitler

Best Answer

Lol! Ain't his fault this time.

Best Answer

That's actually not correct, even before WW1 and WW2 a lot of Jews were beggining to go back to Israel.

Best Answer

Correction without Hitler there wouldn't be Isreal 2 electric boogaloo

Best Answer

Fine then I blame God.

Best Answer

But the Balfour Declaration still faced opposition by many people ...Hitler help convert the world to the idea that the Jewish people deserved/needed a homeland within Palestine.

Best Answer

The main reason why a lot of the Jews returned to Israel in the first place was because they were being persecuted all over Europe. They had (and have) every right to return to their country.

Best Answer

During World War I, the Zionist cause gained some degree of support from Great Britain. In a 1917 letter from British foreign secretary Lord Balfour to Jewish financier Lord Rothschild, the British government expressed a commitment to creating a Jewish homeland in Palestine. This letter is commonly known as the Balfour Declaration. Unfortunately, the British were speaking out of both sides of their mouth, simultaneously promising Arabs their freedom if they helped to defeat the Ottoman Empire, which at that time controlled most of the Middle East (including the modern states of Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and Iraq, as well as significant portions of Saudi Arabia and northern Africa). The British promised the Arabs that they would limit Jewish settlement in Palestine mere months after the Balfour Declaration expressed support for "the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people."

Best Answer

The Holocaust brought the need for a Jewish homeland into sharp focus for both Jews and for the rest of the world. The Jews who tried to flee Nazi Germany were often turned back due to immigration limitations at the borders of every country, including the United States, Britain and Palestine. Many of those who were sent back to Germany ended up in death camps where they were systematically murdered.

Best Answer
5 More Responses

Religion!

Best Answer

Bingo that is the correct answer, smartest thing i heard yet

Best Answer

Religion is only part of it. Land is the main issue.

Best Answer

Yes, land is the issue, but it's Religious Beliefs why both sides claim ownership of the same land. It's a no-win situation unless such beliefs can be set aside for ever.

Best Answer

Oh really? how would you act if Mexico or Canada had drones over you country, build huge walls around your border, kept you in like pigs, walking in your country when they please, shooting family's dead, ransacking houses, stealing land? eh, how would you react ? i would slaughter as many of them as i can, The Zionists do not belong in Israel. Israel will have its day, "you can't fool all of the people, all of the time"

Best Answer

I'm just looking at the facts. Historically, Israel has always belonged to the Jews. Of course, the Jews aren't absolutely blameless but I don't think they actually want this war to keep continuing. As for the Jews doing all of the things you have suggested, the Arabs have also done these things. In fact, far worse things. Israel would completely stop all of this warfare if the Arabs (Palestinians especially) would stop targeting their country. It's the Palestinians that want to take land, not the Jews. They gave them most of the Gaza ***** a few years ago, so if anything, they have submitted land to them.

Best Answer

Great answer. Radical Zionists are largely responsible.

Best Answer

Minorities on both sides. I bet if you put it to a popular vote, "do you want the borders to stay as they are if it means all the fighting stops for good", the majority in both countries would sign up in an instant.



The problem is brinksmanship. You can decide if YOUR side stops fighting, but you can't stop the other side from fighting without fighting back yourself. That's what all these peace treaties are supposed to do. But peace is a one day at a time thing; it's never going to be "achieved", it's just possible that it can pick up some momentum and become easier to maintain. As long as no-one attacks anyone and collapses the whole thing.

Best Answer

Hamas is a lot to blame for what is currently going on. I'm sure a lot of Islamic people do desire peace, but a lot are being manipulated by powerful leaders. There is also a tremendous amount of oppression they have to endure. Even if a group of peace-seeking Arabic people did get together, they would probably be persecuted for it by their own country. A lot of the civilians are too scared to fight for peace because it is mostly discouraged over there. As for the Israelis, I do believe they want peace. But it's not possible if your country is under attack. If Israel did submit, the Arab states would most likely take advantage and see it as an opportunity to continue their attacks. If the Arabic states submitted and called an end to the violence, Israel would probably stop their attacks. What they do is a form of self-defence, what the Arabs do is a form of antagonism.

Best Answer

I don't know. Hamas do worse things, no doubt, but it seems to me that Israel as a wealthy developed nation should be held to a higher standard. The nature of their "retaliation" (didn't the current spate of violence start with their assassinating a Hamas leader?) is disproportionate, and continued despite the heavy loss of civilian life. In fact if I were going to be really cynical, the goal for both sides seems to be maximising Palestinian civilian deaths and blaming it on the other lot, hoping to discredit them.

Best Answer

Related Questions