Fictional Fights Are Fought And Won In The Author's Mimd

The question was

Who would win a fight between two A and B (who happen to be two fictional characters?)

These are fictional characters, right? So wouldn't it depend on what was written for them? People have to write the scripts. Make up the stories. You decide who would win; then you write it that way.

Or have I got that wrong?
Serenitree Serenitree
70+, F
Jan 6, 2013