I Miss Peter Pan Peanut Butter

due to a massive recall a few months ago, peter pan peanut butter has been taken off the grocery shelves.  i loved the reduced fat kind!
reachin4goals reachin4goals
31-35, F
5 Responses Jul 31, 2007

I loved PP PB too...it is back now BUT a great substitute was the Honey Roasted REESE'S brand. Yum-O!

They make a honey roasted one now!! AS if there wasn't enough sugar in the original recipe. I bought 3 jars of it. Yummy!!

I always thought that their crunchy peanut butter was the CRUNCHIEST!!! yum!

they sell it at safeway where I live

Guess what!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was just at the grocery store and saw those magical jars on the shelves. Peter Pan Peanut butter is back in town! Hmmm, I wonder if I am brave enough to try it.