First Time With Butt Plug

I am new to this site, but after reading so many stores I decided to join. I am a 20 year old male, and usually very active in my sex life. As my girlfriend, Aly, likes to tell me, I'm usually the "alpha" of our relationship. And so far my girlfriend hasn't complained. Recently though, she shared to me one of her more intimate fantasies. She didn't reveal a lot, but just wanted to be in charge for once. She wanted to make me be submissive. Since I'm open to anything, I agreed to make her fantasy come true. I really had no idea what I was getting into. Then comes a day when my gf asks to have a "play" date. Intrigued by her choice of words, I came over. Aly explained her fantasy, she wanted me to be her puppy. She bought a pair of costume fox ears, a black pair of gloves, a red collar and leash, and the final detail: a shiny black butt-plug with a faux-fur fox tail attached. I had never done this before, especially considering that I thought that Aly just wanted to tie me up and have her way with me. The foxy ears, gloves, collar and leash all went on easily, but the butt plug was an entirely new experience.

I won't lie, I have experimented a little with anal. Aly handed me the fox-tail butt plug and said she wanted to see me put it in, as it would be the ultimate act of submission for her. With plenty of lube, I slowly coaxed the tip of the butt plug in, and my sphincter just clenched around it. Taking deep slow breaths, with Aly petting me of all things, I continued to relax and pushed the butt plug further. Inch by inch it went in. Every inch made me filled fuller and fuller. Eventually, I reached the thickest part of the butt plug. Aly moved so that she could see it go in. With one final breath I pushed it in and just moaned, unused to the feeling of having something in my ***. I was hard, my erection just leaking pre-***. Aly squealed with joy and hugged me. She took my leash and just led me around her house. Just walking around with that butt plug in was so erotic, to feel my muscles pulse around it but realizing that I couldn't take it out.

Aly had me pleasure her, but didn't allow me to receive any pleasure. Little did she know that the butt plug was all the pleasure I needed. ;) For my first time, I managed to sleep with the fox-tail butt plug in me, curled up next to my "master' Aly. I can't wait to experience more. :)
Kinkyfox343 Kinkyfox343 18-21, M 1 Response May 2, 2012

Your Response


Cool! Nice you have this harmonious relationship going. Some of us are not so lucky.

So how big was this thing - length and width? I struggled, too, at first, to put anything inside me. Do keep us informed and have fun!

Thanks for the comment! The butt plug's length was I think around 6in and about 1.5 inches thick. I know there are much bigger plugs out there but I guess this is a one step at time type of thing. :) I'll definitely keep you guys informed!