I Was Given The Wrong Baby
Posted September 27th, 2011 at 7:55PM
My roommate had her new baby also, and I said to her, "this is strange, he doesn't look like my other baby", he was all wrapped up in a receiving blanket, so I didnt even think to look at his ankle bracelet. I just kept staring, thinking this does not feel right, so I decided I would feed him.
Just then I heard screaming down the hall, and the nurse came screaming and yelling into the room, with another baby in an isolette. She yelled :Mrs. Smith, I am so, so, sorry I gave you the wrong baby." I was incredulous
She exchanged babies, and I knew immediately upon holding my son, he was my baby. He looked just like his brother, short, chubby, and tons of dark hair.
Til this day, it's a family joke, we bought home the wrong baby. My son looks just like me, when he was age 7, he looked like me at that age.
So, I did get the right baby, and he was the noisiest baby in the nursery.
-
wow ! this is amazing ! glad you got the right baby ! thanks for sharing ! .....................Peter
-
They DO make mistakes but nobody will ever take you seriously because hospitals have so much prestige and power. A few years ago I had a heart attack in Melbourne, Australia where I live. The ambulance crew and the surgical team at a major public hospital saved my life by unblocking an artery and implanting a cardiovascular stent through a long tube inserted into the carotid artery in my groin. I was conscious the whole time and saw the procedure real-time on one of the monitors the surgical team was using. How many people ever get to see something like that while knockin' on heavens door? That is the end of the good news. I was left naked and shivering in a ward that was so cold I could see my own breath when I exhaled. Meal trolleys were left on the other side of the ward where I could not reach them and students lined up for their turn to poke me but did not seem to notice or care that I was cold, hungry and angry. After three days of being the cardiology 101 exhibit but otherwise ignored, I got dressed and walked out. With no cash or plastic in my pocket I walked home, about two miles. When my daughter told her mum (we're no longer together) she paid me a rare visit and said to my new partner "Sounds typical, he was always difficult."
-
I'm in australia too and this is similar to what happened to my father. I think it atrocious. Doctors are not gods and the staff are there to do a job, which they don't do. Maybe they are understaffed, but Dad was in a private hospital as well, and still got the same treatment you suffered. It's not right. It's not you being difficult, just you wanting care and respect when you need it most. Is that too much to ask for? Glad all turned out well for you in the end.2 more replies -
Not at all funny at the time, but this is the kind of experience that is retold as family history, and as you say become family jokes.
-
wow, that really is something, i think the nurse must have gave me to the wrong parents when i was born, just kidding , i am glad they figured it out ,
-
Wonderful experience Babs! Thank God the nurse did not replace the ankle bracelets of the babies.LOL
-
It's good thing they notice it was the wrong baby; or you would have taken the wrong baby home which will be sad. Mothers do have connections with their babies, and yours was very strong because you felt he was wrong when you held him.
-
just wondering have u and ur family met the other baby u were givin
-
Amazing....I wonder how often this happens and no fix occurs....the new genetic tests are starting to unravel some of these mistakes.
-
Thank you stepping up, yes, I wonder how often it happens, the dna is great. I know
he is ours, for sure. -
I think we need a strategy for dealing with institutions like hospitals that are so prestigious and powerful they are above the law because they are generally above suspicion. I am not suggesting a terrorist attack or guerrilla warfare, just an organized or systematic method of bringing them to account. Maybe they are understaffed, underfunded and under resourced. Why doesn't the administration speak out about it? Are they too well paid to care about what happens at the bottom of the organizational pyramid? I don't expect politicians to fix the crisis in public health funding in Australia where I live, in fact they are part of the problem. How many promises have you heard in the last ten years that they were going to fix it? How much has changed in that time? I have no idea how or where to start working for systematic change in the government healthcare monopoly only that it will not come from the top. Great systematic societal changes always begin as a groundswell of popular opinion which various leaders subsequently attempt to claim as their own. They NEVER start it off in the first place. THAT is up to us. Now, where do we go from here? Any suggestions or ideas?
-
Where I live there is a study and they say that the wrong child is given to the wrong parents what comes out to once a month. NOT good numbers! Some would read this and say that they wish they WOULD have been given to the wrong parents!
-
From Scopes.com - "On average, 12 newborns will be given to the wrong parents every day." -
That is horrifying but at the same time remarkable the power of a mothers bond to her child, it is lucky that the mistake was rectified when you were in the hospital some mothers in the earlier days found out years later the mix up when their children were almost adults, i watched a doco on it a few years back about parents whose children were mixed up at birth, they eventually found each other when their children were 8 but did not swap them back but remarkably remained close in each others lives until the day the children are old enough to be told the truth.
-
I didn't look like anyone in my family until my baby brother was born when I was 13. After 50, I started to look more like my Dad.
-
Hello there, I can't imagine that happening with my little one, now that I think about it, I am glad they gave me my baby four years ago lol. These days they have to match the bracelets with the baby and the mom and also they have like a alarm device on the baby so that no one can not get into the maturity ward and steal the babies. They will not let you in if you are not on the family visit list or anything like that wow. Crazy stuff these days but I am glad that they do that for security and safety of the staff and the patients in there. They actually have a system to where you cant go in there for the double doors are locked. I am so glad you got the right baby heheehe and even if you did not think of anything, you were so willing because of the mother instinct that you wanted to help the other baby too.
-
Glad to hear you got the right baby and the nurse admitted she gave you the wrong baby. But you know even though that was a bad mistake you have to admit the nurse screaming and running back to your room with the right baby is halarious. She is the one who is suppose to remain calm during a situation like that . I can understand if she gave you the wrong baby on the day you were leaveing and alreay headed for the lobby and then relised it.
-
that is so creepy scary!
My sister is the oldest of 5 (actually, our oldest brother died of pnemonia at 9 months before the rest of us came along) but therefore she assumed the role of bossy oldest. LOL
well anyhow dont know why she got the notion but she always thought she was adopted!! To this day we tease her about it -
Wow that is one scary experience, and very nice of you to share :) It makes you think of these "little" mistakes can make a huge difference in one's life..
-
How well I relate to this:
I was born, they took me away to clean me up and I was put with the rest of the new-born babies into a crib in the baby-room. Soon after I was taken to my Mother to feed, along with all the other babies and that's how it was then. Anyway ... I wouldn't feed from my Mother's breast. The nurse slapped my back-side to make me cry and forced me back to her breast, but I still wouldn't feed. And then a lady in the next bed started crying and called out that the baby she had been given was not hers.
It turned out that I was given to the wrong Mother, and my real Mother was in the next bed. After a lot of tears and checks, it was discovered I had been put in the wrong cot. I was given to my real Mother after that and I immediately started to feed.
Which took me to a question, which in turn brought he here.
I have always had a bit of a fear of large breasts and I once told my Mother this. She told me of this very early event in my life and it seemed to make sense; I was slapped for not latching on to feed, a good possible reason as to why large breasts scare me … HA!
~F~ -
I've asked my mom if this might be the case with me, if I might have been switched at the hospital. I am 42 and found out in the last 2 years that there is another man in the province of Manitoba that has the same name as I and we were born 2 weeks apart in the same hospital. At 6'6" and 350 lbs I am the tallest in my family by 8" and I personally don't see any familial similarity to any of my siblings. I have never met the other me so I don't know what he looks like, but wouldn't that be the strangest thing to happen... I'm pretty sure you'd be seeing it on the news!
-
My ex-wife was not given the wrong baby. I could imagine the shock/disbelief/panic.
It would not have been possible for my ex- to get "the wrong baby." My son was born at home with a midwife in attendance in 1988.
A funny sidebar to that came later. I called the city editor of the paper, to put in a birth announcement (the little one-liner like hospitals do.) They told me that they took that information from the hospital records.
After pointing out my son was born at home, the city editor put me on hold, then came back and asked, "Is it okay if we put it under the heading 'at home'?" I assured him that would be better than something like Virginia Beach General Hospital.
'At home' came with another benefit: he was listed first. -
Well, I was born at home in 1960, but I remember little about it. As for my son, the midwife was a CNM. The not-so-nice part of that was, I was still in the Navy at the time. Though the benefits manual for CHAMPUS (military health insurance) stated that midwifery was covered provided the midwife was licensed and a CNM, the overseer of the program at the time was an obstetrician who viewed midwives as "competition." Thus, he kept refusing to authorize payment for the staggering cost of $700, which covered all pre-natal visits, the home birth itself, and six weeks of post-natal visits. On top of that, my immediate supervisor (a single man) did not wish to let me off work on a night when nothing was going on when my ex-wife was in labor, and put me on report for not taking her to a hospital. (That was squelched by my shop supervisor, a woman.)1 more reply
-
Wow. That's an amazing story. Just think; you were THAT close to having a horrible mix up. But I guess 'A Mother knows'.
-
It was good the mistake was fond. It may have been more complicated if you fed him.
-
Thankfully they fond out. It xould have been complicated had you fed him,
-
Knowing right off something wasn't right, mom knows. The mistake thank goodness corrected.and the family joke continues
-
Wow that would have scared me to death!! TG they realized the mistake!
-
scary!
-
that sounds really scary to me... glad it worked out for the best though
-
What a horrifying feeling. It is good that you are able to joke about it. I would have been beside myself. I'm sure the nurse was wigged out she could have lost her job.
Many, many years ago in Chicago someone walked into a hospital ward and took a baby. After that, the hospital installed electronic tags on the babies feet with the name of the mother and all of the doors to the maternity ward are electronic. Nobody comes in or out without someone buzzing them. There are cameras everywhere. -
It has been said, a mother knows her baby's cry from others. In the hospital I told my husband to listen they're bringing our son, they did because I knew it was his cry.
So glad you got the correct baby, a sensitive mother just knows.
1-29 of 29 Comments
29 Comments (add your own)
Sort By