Register

I Watch Documentaries

Some Documentaries May Have Become "lietoyoumentaries"

By: LeisaWolf
Written on January 12th, 2010
By: LeisaWolf
Age: 51-55 , Female
1,642 people have read this story

Your Response

By clicking "Post", you confirm that you agree to the Terms of Service of Experience Project, Inc.
18 responses
  • Youneke

    I like the way you think, your right I've often wondered myself how they maintained vast numbers of people out in the middle of some desert. Another example, Micheal Moore's Bowling for Columbine (I think), he uses an example of coming to Canada and telling how Canadians don't lock their doors when they go out or at night, that is definitely not true. This goes way beyond documentaries though, it's the same for books, the news any form of "facts" or "reality". So many facts and figures are adjusted to sensationalize the story. Documentaries are good though, it makes you think, it makes you wonder, it should make you question though and do a little work to bring up your own facts. It's a good way to learn.

    Nov 9, 2012
    1 like
  • travelyoja

    So true. If I watch one astronomy documentary, then I watch another. Often the information is conflicting or even contradictory. If it bugs me enough, off to live science or whatever I would go.



    I can't stand reality documentaries, they are so dumbed down for the sake of drama. Sigh.

    Jun 25, 2012
    1 like
  • CBK

    i like to watch world on PBS,does any one know about this channel???,,,

    Aug 29, 2011
    1 like
    • horatio313

      no... what is it about?

      Jan 29
      1 like
  • emptyroads

    This is very true; I certainly wouldn't watch a documentary and think that suddenly I knew everything about the subject.



    For me, it just gets my toes wet in a pop. TV way, and gets me interested enough to find out more.



    Most documentaries have a bias or an 'argument' that they are trying to convince you of.

    Jul 25, 2010
    1 like
  • sophrai

    "The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt. " Bertrand Russell

    Apr 23, 2010
    2 likes
  • LeisaWolf

    Very good comment , Danjya. You opened my eyes to another 'truth', that truth is subjective. If we let ourselves 'believe' something, it is our interpretation of it. I agree about the mental trap. Thanks for adding something valuable to this story, another side that totally makes sense, and lets documentaries off the hook a bit. I still think that you can not rely on them to tell the whole truth about a subject, they do have agendas.

    Mar 1, 2010
    1 like
  • Danjya

    Indeed, a documentary is a subjective statement of a production team - including a filmmaker, producer, cameraman, etc. If you get to see that documentary, add to the production team the subjective perspective on the market of the marketing team that made it possible for you to actually see it. That is not to say that documentaries are no valuable. They represent a way to interpret and convey a message about something. If we take that as an absolute truth, we are lying to ourselves big time. Take it from a filmmaker :)



    The issue however is not whether the documentary tells the truth, but OUR obsessiveness with the TRUTH. It reflects our insecurity with living in a state of informational uncertainty and the underlying conditioning we have all been subjected for as long as we have been using - as a species - any form of language.



    There is a saying that goes like this: "the truth shall set you free". This implies and conditions our brain to believe/interpret that we are not free. It also creates an expectation of what the "truth" can do - set you free. This, is a never ending mental trap. The truth, ymho, is irrelevant. When we stop chasing the truth, we set ourselves free from what the "truth" actually is - an interpretation, a point of view, an incomplete set of data.



    That being said, I love watching documentaries - even when I know exactly what degree of informational manipulation they have embedded within.



    Danjya,

    www.evolutionaryexploration.com

    Feb 25, 2010
    3 likes
  • LeisaWolf

    You got it usmcvince, some people just can't see it, though, they believe what they're told and take no grains of salt with it.

    *** grano salis:

    means "to have intelligence and reasoning capabilities"

    Feb 18, 2010
    1 like
  • usmcvince

    I completely agree with easilyme "Posted by easilyme on Feb 13th, 2010 at 6:04PM "......

    Like anything, documentaries can be politicly charged with some form of special interest.

    Feb 18, 2010
    1 like
  • CallmeMrs

    I don't take documentaries to heart either. On the whole, I find them very interesting and even, depending on what is being aired, entertaining. Trust no one, believe nothing. :D

    Feb 13, 2010
    1 like
  • AlternateSource

    There is a recent one out: "Michael Moore Hates America" In this documentary, the maker is brought face to face with the same issues he starts out chastising Michael Moore for. A documentary starts out with a purpose in mind, but it ends up with the makers dealing with what they managed to gather. The end result is not quite what they hoped to create.

    Feb 13, 2010
    1 like
  • easilyme

    Great point. A documentary is like any other form of media. It is manipulated in certain way to express the opinion of the director. You can find an "expert" in any topic to tell you one thing and then find another that will tell you the complete opposite. Documentarians will only show you what they want you to see and hear and they way they want you to see and hear it.

    Feb 13, 2010
    1 like
  • gryfnn

    I was just thinking about, "And this concerns me how?" I have been blessed with the ability to read and write... books have meant so much to me in my long lifetime.....For many years I have sponsored a little girl in Africa. She is now a grown up young lady. I still sponsor her, because I want her to be able to continue her education... she can read and write....I feel so privileged that I have been able to gift someone with that precious ability.....This is what I mean by "And this concerns me how?" Truth has many ways that a person can access---I am not sure if "belief" is something one needs to commit to. "Trust" is a necessary attribute---one must be very cautious before "trusting".

    Jan 13, 2010
    1 like
  • gryfnn

    The first time I heard, "And this concerns me how?" was from one of my grandkids. I don't know who said it originally. There is great wisdom in that question. Each of us have a place in this world.

    Some of us have more influence than others. Perhaps, if each of us apply ourselves to making our part of the world better........then at least "truth" will exist and be obvious within our own experience.

    Jan 13, 2010
    1 like
  • praxeus169

    Deductive reasoning is only as good as the deducer and his/her knowledge. learn your history and basic logistics. However, your conclusion is axiomatically correct.

    Jan 13, 2010
    3 likes
  • LeisaWolf

    Please refer to my new story "War of Words - The Peaceful Revolution" for more on how we perceive television information and the written word.

    Jan 12, 2010
    2 likes
  • stardark

    so so true, we can believe ?? who can we believe, we are never given all the facts or even any facts and so much is hidden from us

    i am sorry but the human race ....i do not want to be impolite ..but really

    Jan 12, 2010
    1 like